High Grade worked for us.  No leaks after 6+ years and left no damage or mess behind.  Pricing was the best as well

we used High Grade in 2002 or 2003 to do a total reroof. They also changed out 3 of our skylights, but did not finish the inside (just the outside portion) for a very good price.

They came on a slightly drizzly day after a summer of a lot of rain, with about 2 crews (about 13 men!). I have not had a leak since and the skylights are good -had to hire someone else to complete  the inside for the skylights-moulding and painting).

They did leave some roof pieces around -I guess they were in a rush-they came about 7 in the morning and left around 4 p.m with a double crew.  They had used our deck for a place to put the roofing mateial and make some cuts. I noticed that two of my deck pressure treated wood panels had cut marks as it was not covered and I told them about it and held back $500. At first they did not want to change the pressure treated wood boards. I said I will not pay until they change, it so they came back the next day and changed them-the boss was not happy-but they did it and I paid them.The roof is good! and we had a few hurricanes.

good luck Donna

Thanks for all the recommendations.  We got a few quotes and eventually went with High Grade - there was a lower quote from another roofer, but we called to compare and they beat the price.  They scheduled an appointment within a couple weeks of us returning their contract, called to confirm a couple days before, and did the work in one day.  We found a single nail and piece of old shingle in the yard afterwards, but I'd call that very good cleanup.

Definitely happy with their work!

Steve